Thursday, March 17, 2022

Revisting The Defeo Murders : The Victimization of Ronnie " Butch" Defeo JR

They say  that  when  someone  becomes infamous for all  the  wrong  reasons, it  can  cause irreparable damage  to  the person who  wants  to  be  left alone .As we all  know when you  receive too much  negative attention, the  first  initial  reaction  you have  is  anger  towards  those  people and  yourself. 


The  fact  is people really don't care  or realize how much it can affect you in the  long run. More importantly,   it can definitely leave a very bitter  taste in your  mouth. Truth is you  just want  it all to be done and  over  with. 

Unfortunately life doesn't always    work out in our favor ! You  can't change past, and you sure as hell  can't  predict the  future  either or  think  about  what  if  I  hadn't   done  what  I  did ?

And as  hard of a  pill  it  is  to  swallow,  you  have  to  fight  to  make yourself  be heard and make people  listen to  you even if it falls on  deaf  ears.


People tend to have warped negative preconceived notions about  you , your  life  and  think  they  know who  you  are  when  they  truly don't. 


On March 12th 2021, the  man known as the Amityville NY Mass Murderer passed away  in  a  prison  hospital.  

To his loves ones he was  simply  known as  Ronnie  Joseph " Butch " Defeo Jr.

Ronnie had all  he  ever wanted  handed  to  him  ,but  behind  closed  doors , his  family was plagued with physical  , mental ,  alcohol and drug abuse. 


He never  asked  to  be  born into the family  he  was, hell  most  of  all he  didn't ask  for  the  media attention that engulfed him the rest  of his life .


All because of one faithful night  in  Ñovember 1974 that would lead to the  deaths of his family. It set  a  media  frenzy that spanned  over  46  years.


The media  attention he received, the haunting  and  the court case that  proceeded them angered him to  no end . A word to the  wise  he  became  an urban  legend but  not  by choice. 


Truthfully speaking  upon watching The Amityville 2 : possession, The Amityville Murders and reading the  real  story  The Night  the  Defeos died  by  Ric  Osuna  my  eyes  were  wide  open.

I began  to  see a  different  side to  Butch than the  so called monster he's  perceived to be. He was a human  being  whose  story  needed  to  be  heard .

For me  , my  journey  into totally  understanding him began after  I saw Ryan Katzenbach's 2014 documentary Shattered  Hopes  :  The  True  Story  of  the Amityville Murders.

It is  based on  the  Book The  Night The  Defeos died ( a play  on  the  song The  night  Chicago  died) which is mentioned above. To be  honest  with you I  wanted to see  the  interview  with  Butch Defeo .

I  was  impressed  by what I  heard and it did not disappoint me  at  all. I  learned  that  sometimes what we  believe  and what we thought we knew is based on gossip and baseless nasty rumors.

These are things people that  knew him  have  said  in  past interviews and  articles that should  never see the  light  of day ever again in our  life time  . 

I 1000 % believed before watching  the interview with  him that  he  was  not  fully  responsible  for  the  Murders.

I  wanted  to  know if  my theories  were  correct and  amazingly  enough my  gut  instincts  were  correct.

Let me tell you, Ronnie "Butch" Defeo definitely  made more  than a huge impression  on  me .In fact, he made me sit up and take  notice when he spoke! 

All the things I had questions  about and thought about  were  exactly what  he  expressed to  Ryan  Katzenbach in the full  interview .

Until you walk a mile in someone else's shoes,  and even walk the path in  life  they  walked upon, you  have no right  to judge Ronnie . 

Did  he  make an impulsive  decision to  what  he  did  ? Yes! did he  act  alone  in  the  killings ?


Hell No, I  believe  him  when he  said  Dawn helped  him  in the  shooting that  killed his  family  and  that he  killed Dawn in  self  defense after  she  attacked him.

Even the Prosecutor Gerard Sullivan had said  that  he felt  that  Ronnie  had  help  in the  attack  upon  his  family . 

You will  never begin to fathom all he , his  siblings  and  mom went through in  his  life  before  the  Murders  took place.


It's  just  crazy  that  people  offer  an  opinion on someone they  hardly  know. Offering  a  view  point  is  good  as long  as  you do  thorough research.

Listening to him speak his  truth  made  me aware  ,  that  he  was wrongly  done  by  , by  the  people  who were  supposed to love, support  and protect him.

He said he  was  an errand  boy for  the  mob and that he knew things  that  could cause alot  of  drama.


Including  the fact  that  he  knew  which cops and judges  were on  the  take and  could  expose  the  truth. 

He  said  he  knew  this  because   , he  would  deliver  the  pay  offs from his grandfather .And  hearing  about  Ronnie being  beaten  by  his  dad  on  a regular  basis disgusted  me .

One  incident  he  got  beat  up   for making  a  simple  statement  like " I  was  picking up a napkin and  never  left  the  table pop!" Would  set  Ronnie  SR off and  Ronnie would  get  a beating. 

The  other  kids got their  share  of   beatings  as did  their  mom. 

One  story  we  heard  was  Dawn  staged a kidnapping to  extort  money from her  grandfather  so  she  could  run away  to  Florida to  be  with  her boyfriend  .

Ronnie  SR  refused to  let  her  go  and  she  got  a  slap  for  standing  up  to  him  even  resorting to  threatening him  with  a  knife. 

She and Butch on countless occasions ,would  try to  ask  for  help  , but  when the  cries  for  help  from  Ronnie  and  Dawn  came  everyone turned  a deaf  ear  to  it.

There I  said  it ! I  am  putting  the  blame on  his  grandfather's and  the  rest  of  his  family  .

The  deaths  of  all  6  of  Ronnie's  family would  not  have  happened  if  the  grandparents stopped  and  listened  to  the  kids .

Stepping  up  and  dealing  with  the  situation to protect  them  all  would  have  been  alot better  than  turning  a  blind  eye  to  it  all.

GASLIGHTING RONNIE  DEFEO  JR


Upon